Papa Kelsey's Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to Papa Kelsey's, your go-to destination in Twin Falls for mouthwatering subs and delightful sides! Nestled at 637 Blue Lakes Blvd N, this eatery is celebrated for its fresh, baked-to-order subs that promise a feast for the senses.
- Signature Subs: Try the Southwest Chipotle Chicken or the Triple Meat Sub, both crowd favorites drawing rave reviews from locals.
- Irresistible Sides: Don’t miss their Garlic Cheese Bread, served with marinara — perfect for sharing or enjoying solo.
- Customer Favorites: Guests rave about the hearty 3 Meat Sub and the fantastic Italian sub, proving the quality and flavor keeps them coming back.
With friendly service and a cozy atmosphere, Papa Kelsey's is more than a restaurant; it's a community favorite brimming with flavor and hospitality!
Fountain Drinks
Small Drink 16 Oz
Large Drink 32 Oz
Kids Drink 12 Oz
Medium Drink 22 Oz
Pizza Sub
Pepperoni, mozzarella cheese & pizza sauce
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub
Grilled chicken, bacon, mozzarella cheese & ranch dressing
Turkey BLT Sub
Turkey breast, bacon, mozzarella cheese, tomato, lettuce & mayo
Wrangler Sub
Steak, mushroom, onion, pineapple, mozzarella cheese & BBQ sauce
Ham & Cheese Sub
Ham, mozzarella cheese, tomato & mayo
Ham & Turkey Sub
Ham, turkey breast, mozzarella cheese, tomato, lettuce & mayo
Chicken Malibu Sub
Lightly breaded chicken, ham, honey mustard, mozzarella cheese, tomato, lettuce & mayo
Steak Firehouse Sub
Taco Sub
Taco meat, black olive, onion, mozzarella cheese, sour cream, tomato, lettuce & enchilada sauce
Turkey Supreme Sub
Turkey breast, mozzarella cheese, Swiss cheese, tomato & mayo
Brisket Sub
Smoked brisket, mozzarella cheese, light BBQ sauce & mayo
Italian Combo Sub
Ham, Italian sausage, salami, onion, green pepper, mushroom, mozzarella cheese, tomato & mayo
Chicken Firehouse Sub
Southwest Chipotle Steak Sub
Steak, green pepper, mushroom, Swiss cheese, mozzarella cheese, mayo & chipotle ranch
Roast Beef Sub
Roast beef, mozzarella cheese, tomato & mayo
Veggie Sub
Black olive, onion, green pepper, mushroom, mozzarella cheese, tomato & mayo
Triple Meat Sub
Ham, turkey breast, roast beef, mozzarella cheese, tomato & mayo
Meatball Sub
Meatballs, Italian sausage, roasting pepper, pizza sauce & mozzarella cheese
French Dip Sub
Roast beef, onion, mozzarella cheese & served with au jus
Southwest Chipotle Chicken Sub
Grilled chicken, green pepper, mushroom, Swiss cheese, mozzarella cheese, mayo & chipotle ranch
Steak & Everything Sub
Steak, onion, mushroom, green pepper, roasting pepper, mozzarella cheese & swiss cheese
Baked Subs
Soups & Salads
Taco Salad
Lettuce, black olive, tomato, doritos, onion, taco meat & mozzarella cheese
Bread Bowl
Mandarin Chicken Salad
Lettuce, grilled chicken, chow mein noodles, slivered almonds, mozzarella cheese & mandarin oranges
Italian Salad
Lettuce, pepperoni, black olive, mozzarella cheese & homemade croutons
Chicken Salad
Lettuce, grilled or crispy chicken, tomato, onion, mozzarella cheese & homemade croutons
Southwest Chipotle Chicken Salad
Lettuce, grilled chicken, green pepper, mushroom & mozzarella cheese
Chef Salad
Lettuce, ham, turkey, tomato, mozzarella cheese & homemade croutons
Southwest Chipotle Steak Salad
Lettuce, steak, green pepper, mushroom & mozzarella cheese
Soup Of The Day
Limited quantities daily. Monday-creamy chicken & wild rice. Tuesday - creamy potato with bacon. Wednesday - Cheddar Broccoli. Thursday - Chili with brisket. Friday - Tomato, basil bisque. Saturday - White Cheddar mac & cheese
Turkey Bacon Salad
Lettuce, turkey, bacon, tomato, mozzarella cheese & homemade croutons
Root Beer 2 Liter
Cherry Pepsi 2 Liter
Mountain Dew 2 Liter
Pepsi 2 Liter
Diet Pepsi 2 Liter
Starry Lemon Lime 2 Liter
20 oz bottle
2 Liter
20 Oz
Root Beer 20oz
20 oz bottle
Diet Pepsi 20oz
20 oz bottle
Mountain Dew 20oz
20 oz bottle
Pepsi 20oz
20 oz bottle
Cinnamon Roll
Cookie
Desserts
Kid's Menu
Kid's Menu
Bottled Water
Bottled Water
Sides
French Fries
Regular or spicy oven baked fries. Served with our house-made fry sauce.
22oz. Medium Cup Of Ranch
Additional Chipotle Ranch
Additional Raspberry Vinaigrette
Additional Mayonnaise
Additional Blue Cheese
Garlic Cheese Bread
Butter, garlic & mozzarella cheese. Served with a side of marinara sauce
Additional Honey Mustard
Additional Asian Sesame
Parmesan Sticks
Additional BBQ Sauce
Additional Chip
Additional Au Jus
Additional Italian Dressing
Additional Fry Sauce
Additional Sour Cream
Additional Marinara Sauce
Additional Salsa
Additional Ranch
16oz. Small Cup Of Ranch
Additional 1000 Island
Taco Pizza
Enchilada sauce, taco meat, onion, black olive, Doritos, lettuce, tomato, sour cream & mozzarella cheese
All Meat Supreme Pizza
Pizza sauce, Italian sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, bacon crumble & mozzarella cheese
Papa Kelsey's Special Pizza
Pizza sauce, ham, Italian sausage, black olive, onion, green pepper, mushroom & mozzarella cheese
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Ranch dressing, grilled chicken, bacon & mozzarella cheese
Hawaiian Pizza
Pizza sauce, Canadian bacon, pineapple & mozzarella cheese
Fred's Delight Pizza
Pizza sauce, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, green pepper, mushroom & mozzarella cheese
Vegetarian Pizza
Pizza sauce, black olive, onion, green pepper, mushroom, tomatoes & mozzarella cheese
Cheese Pizza
Pizza sauce & mozzarella cheese
BBQ Chicken Pizza
BBQ sauce, grilled chicken, onion, bacon & mozzarella cheese
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza sauce, pepperoni & mozzarella cheese